Tag Archives: aluminum

Air Pollution, Aluminum, and Vitamin D Deficiency Linked to Dementia Risk

A recent meta-analysis published in BMC Geriatrics analyzed 60 human studies of environmental risk factors for dementia. The authors of the paper applied statistical analysis based on the overall quality of each study (i.e., the highest quality papers had a larger sample size and robust measures of exposure and outcome) in order to synthesize their results into broader conclusions. Based on these calculations, they assigned each risk factor a score based on the strength of the evidence for its involvement in dementia. A “strong” score indicates solid evidence linking a risk factor to dementia, while “moderate” or “weak” scores suggest that more research needs to be done before a conclusion can be drawn.

Air Pollution

Air pollution was concluded to be a significant risk factor for dementia based on the results of eight independent studies. Sources of air pollution with strong scores included nitrogen oxides, particulate matter (such as dust, smoke, and soot), and ozone, while carbon monoxide and environmental tobacco smoke received a moderate score. Major sources of air pollution include cars, construction sites, industrial smokestacks, and power plants. Individuals living in urban areas may want to consider investing in home air filters in order to reduce their exposure to air pollution.

Metals and Micronutrients

If you’ve read my article on the role of metals in Alzheimer’s disease, you know that certain metals are correlated with an increased risk of Alzheimer’s, though the evidence is still not conclusive enough to say for sure whether they contribute directly to the development of dementia. The meta-analysis confirmed this interpretation. Most of the metals in the analysis (including lead, copper, iron, and zinc) were given a weak score. The only metals to earn a moderate score were aluminum and arsenic. My article mentioned above includes some easy tips for reducing your exposure to aluminum and other metals.

In addition, two micronutrients were identified as potential dementia risk factors when consumed above recommended dosages. Selenium, which is found in meat, seafood, dairy products, and mushrooms, scored moderate on the risk scale. Silica, a mineral found at varying concentrations in drinking water, scored high risk. Though small amounts of both these minerals are important for health, it may be best to avoid taking them in supplement form (unless instructed by a physician) in order to avoid over-consumption.

Occupational Exposure

The review also analyzed studies on exposure to potentially-harmful substances in the workplace. Pesticides and fertilizers were identified as high risk factors, a worrying find for those in the agricultural industry. This may explain why children living in rural areas are at higher risk for dementia as adults, which was concluded in a previous meta-analysis by the same authors. Exposure to industrial solvents or degreasers was also a high risk factor. The occupational factors rated at moderate risk included metals, diesel motor exhaust, and (strangely enough) electromagnetic fields. The latter finding remains highly controversial.

Vitamin D

The evidence analyzed in this study identified vitamin D deficiency as a strong risk factor for dementia. This finding was supported by three independent studies of more than 15,000 subjects in total, though one small study involving 40 subjects did not find an association. Vitamin D is not easily obtained through food. However, our body can synthesize vitamin D when our bare skin (without sunscreen) is exposed to sunlight. The time required to meet our daily dose of vitamin D depends on your skin tone, the amount of sunlight available, and how much skin you have exposed. On a sunny summer day, 10-15 minutes is often enough. You may want to consider taking vitamin D supplements during the winter, if you live in an often-cloudy area, or if you do not go outside every day.

Concluding Remarks

The authors of this paper noted several sources of bias in their meta-analysis. An important consideration is that the studies have been conducted almost exclusively in high-income countries, despite the highest rates of dementia occurring in low- to middle-income countries. Additionally, since none of these studies measured exposure at more than one time point, the data can’t predict whether any critical periods exist for exposure to these risk factors. In other words, exposure may be more harmful during old age than childhood, or vice versa. Finally, as with any observational study, it’s important to keep in mind that these risk factors may not all be causal (see How to Be a Smart Consumer of Science News).

Despite these sources of error or bias, the exposures identified as high or moderate risk factors for dementia should not be taken lightly. Some of them are easier to avoid than others, but it makes sense that we should all take whatever steps we can to reduce our risk of dementia.

 

Enjoy this post? Help it to grow by sharing on social media!
Want more? Follow AlzScience via email or like us on Facebook!

The Role of Metals in Alzheimer’s Disease

Small amounts of certain metals, such as zinc, copper, and iron, are necessary for our bodies to function properly. These are referred to as biometals. Other metals like aluminum are not needed for survival but can be tolerated by the body in low doses. However, for reasons that remain unclear, studies have shown that patients with Alzheimer’s disease often have an imbalance of these metal ions in their brains. Abnormally high concentrations of the aforementioned metals have been found inside of amyloid-beta plaques, the toxic protein deposits that are the hallmark of the Alzheimer’s brain [1]. This observation led some scientists to propose the metal theory of Alzheimer’s disease, which suggests that regular exposure to metals can lead to the development of Alzheimer’s [2]. In this article I briefly will evaluate the evidence for and against the metal theory, and describe how it may affect your life.

Aluminum

Aluminum was the first metal that was proposed as a possible cause for Alzheimer’s disease, leading to panic about the aluminum found in soda cans, cookwear, and many processed foods. Back in 1965, researchers showed that rabbits injected with aluminum developed toxic tau fibrils in their brains [3] [4]. Multiple studies have since verified this finding in mice, rats, cats, and monkeys [5].

More than sixty years after the initial experiments, we still have not come to a consensus on whether aluminum exposure can lead to Alzheimer’s. Studies have demonstrated that only levels of aluminum far exceeding those found in the body are capable of promoting amyloid-beta aggregation [6]. In addition, multiple studies have failed to find an association between exposure to aluminum (within normal safety guidelines) and risk of Alzheimer’s. On the other hand, experiments in which rats are chronically exposed to aluminum show accumulation of aluminum in their brains, particularly in the hippocampus (the brain’s memory center). These rats experienced memory impairments as a result of their aluminum exposure [5]. Overall, it’s possible that aluminum contributes in some form to the pathology of Alzheimer’s, but there is not enough evidence to conclude a causative relationship.

Zinc, Copper, and Iron

The biometals zinc, copper, and iron play a variety of important roles in the brain, including cell signaling and neuroplasticity. However, too much of these metals may be harmful for our health. In cell cultures, physiological concentrations of zinc and iron (possibly copper as well, but this is less clear) can promote the formation of amyloid-beta plaques [7]. In addition, all three of these biometals can accelerate the aggregation of tau, another toxic protein found in Alzheimer’s disease. Copper and iron are also believed to contribute to oxidative stress [8]. Oxidative stress is a chemical process involving free oxygen radicals that gradually leads to cell damage and aging; the reason antioxidants are good for you is because they get rid of these free oxygen radicals.

Despite these results, there’s more to the biometals than meets the eye, particularly for zinc. The so-called “zinc paradox” arises from seemingly-contradictory evidence suggesting that zinc can also be neuroprotective in Alzheimer’s disease. When zinc binds to amyloid-beta, it changes the protein’s shape such that its toxicity is reduced. Thus it seems that zinc can stimulate amyloid-beta aggregation but also reduces the toxicity of these aggregates [9]. More research is needed to conclusively determine whether zinc is helpful or harmful in the long-run.

As a rule, most researchers agree that these biometals are likely involved in some way in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer’s disease, but there’s debate on whether they play a directly caustive role. It’s also unclear whether risk can be modulated by dietary or environmental exposure to these metals. For example, certain neurological events (such as a stroke or traumatic brain injury) can increase the levels of metal ions in the brain, so it’s possible that internal rather than external sources are to blame [10].

Other Metals

Though the four metals described above have been the main focus of Alzheimer’s metallobiology research, it’s possible that others could be involved as well. A small number of studies have drawn connections between Alzheimer’s and lead, cobalt, cadmium, and manganese, among others. Though there is not nearly enough evidence to make any definitive claims regarding the involvement of these metals in Alzheimer’s, they raise the possibility that the onset of Alzheimer’s could be exacerbated by chronic exposure to multiple metals simultaneously [11].

Metal Chelators as Alzheimer’s Drugs

If metals are indeed involved in the development of Alzheimer’s, it follows that metal chelators could be useful in the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease. Chelators are compounds that bind to metal ions and help to expel them from the body. Several types of chelators have been tested in animal and human trials for Alzheimer’s. Many of these drugs showed promise, but none have been approved for patient use, most often due to severe side effects. Current research is working to improve these early drugs and make them safer for widespread use [8].

Reducing Exposure to Metals

At present, there simply isn’t enough evidence to conclusively say that exposure to common metals can lead to Alzheimer’s disease. The most likely possibility is that metal exposure alone is not sufficient to cause Alzheimer’s, but it may contribute to disease pathology in combination with other factors including genetics, diet, exercise, and mental stimulation.

However, this does not necessarily mean that we shouldn’t take steps to reduce our exposure to metals. Just because there’s not enough evidence now, doesn’t mean more won’t arise in the future. Reducing daily exposure to metals is simple enough that no harm is done even if they turn out to be innocuous in the end. Here are a few easy tips you can consider [12]:

  • Unless instructed by a doctor, avoid vitamins or supplements contain very high levels of zinc, copper, or iron. Most people who consume a balanced diet have no need for biometal supplements. Shellfish, meats, and nuts are the best dietary sources of biometals. If you do choose to take supplements, do not exceed 100% of the daily recommended value.
  • If your drinking water comes from copper pipes or faucets, run the water for 15-30 seconds each morning before drinking.
  • Reduce your intake of red meat and highly processed foods.
  • The levels of aluminum or copper in cookwear are generally considered safe, but may increase when they are used to cook highly acidic foods (such as spicy foods or tomato sauce). Consider switching to glass or stainless steel.
  • Limit your use of antacids and aspirins that contain aluminum.
  • When baking, use parchment paper instead of foil.
Enjoy this post? Help it to grow by sharing on social media!
Want more? Follow AlzScience via email or like us on Facebook!